| Author |
Topic:
Are We Different From Fans of Other Artists?? |
| KyleWilliam |
posted
05-19-2000 11:47 AM PT (US)
Are we a different breed altogether? I mean, are there fans of other bands
that have such a community and a passion? Are people seeing 15 Creed shows
a tour? Who in fact plays more than 2-3 nights anywhere but Bruce? Will
this community fall apart after the tour, or does the man and his music
keep it al going? Just curious . . . your ideas?? |
| Gokart
Mozart |
posted
05-19-2000 12:15 PM PT (US)
Spooky, just thinking the same thought yesterday. My feeling is that fans
of other bands tend to be either passionate about the music, or the song
writing or the peformer. With Bruce of course it's all three whole is far
greater than the sum of the individual parts. It's a spirtual experience
right?
It's difficult to imagine anyone feeling as passionately about another
band because I know that no other artist evokes emotions in the same way
as Mr S and has created songs to which I have to close my eyes when I play
them.
Of course I may be biased!
As for keeping this going after the tour - it's essential. IF this is
the last tour, I for one am going to have to join a support group or
something!!! |
| Lisabrucefan |
posted
05-19-2000 12:53 PM PT (US)
I think we are very different from fans of other artists. It's one thing
to be "fanatical" about an artist or band while they're HOT -
like the way the "kids" felt about Guns and Roses or Nirvana or
believe it or not Garth Brooks has a hugh involved fan following. But
we're all here for the long haul during the exiciting touring new CD times
and the quiet just waiting for something to happen times. Once I found
Bruce I knew there would be NO ONE else I would relate to the same way for
the rest of my life !!! And unfortunately for me I have practically
stopped going to Any other concerts because they are a dissapointment in
comparrison. They have to be.
And no fans but Bruce fans, with the notable exception of the now defunct
Dead Heads , see multiple shows like Bruce fans do. We don't want to miss
one song, one of his expressions, one pelvic thrust (that one's for the
ladies ) or we're very dissapointed. I agree with Gokart Mazart - we're in
it for the whole experience,the religion of it, the feeling of unity and
belonging.
Bruce possess so much POWER. Sometimes I wish he would find a universal
cause and mobilize us all as soldiers of change. I know he works on Hunger
issues and I know it's not his responsibilty or his job and some might
resent it but there are so many of us worldwide and following him we would
have so much power. |
| Miami
MArk |
posted
05-19-2000 03:56 PM PT (US)
I think some can become over indulgent in their adulation. Other bands and
groups have the same sort of following's it is just not as publicized.
When Bruce goes on tour it becomes an "event". The reason it is
so hard to get tickets is because some people who go to see Bruce go just
to say they were there. I even feel myself at times get that " well I
am going to more shows than you" feeling. I guess the bottom line is
I go because it is fun. It makes me feel good, and it makes me feel alive.
It DOES NOT make me feel different. Actually there are times when I am on
line (outside in the cold/heat not at a pc)that I feel like a lemming. You
know, why exactly am I doing this? But you know, phish and Jimmy Buffet
and Bob Dylan and The Other Ones, and on and on all sell out. Bruce just
happens to have hit a chord in OUR soul. Hell I don't dress different
because of Bruce (except for that bandana thing in the 80's), I do not
agree with all his causes....but I love when he does She's the One....so I
keep going....for the past 25 years I have kept going. |
| BillsBruce |
posted
05-19-2000 04:04 PM PT (US)
I pass a lady driving her car on the way to work each day whose license
plate reads "MANILOW". Now, are you going to tell her that we're
more intense, that we like our guy more than she likes hers?
HELL YES!! :)
|
| tickbitty |
posted
05-19-2000 05:17 PM PT (US)
That's probably Barry's Mom! :) |
| Fred |
posted
05-19-2000 05:54 PM PT (US)
Interesting topic, difficult to answer. I know some Bruce fans that are
pretty casual about it. Music means different things to different people;
to me it's only life and death.
I have been to several Melissa Etheridge shows(my second fav artist right
behind Bruce) and her fans are pretty intense in their feelings for her.
That doesn't surprise me because she comes as close as anyone to making me
feel how Bruce's music makes me feel. |
| karen |
posted
05-19-2000 06:45 PM PT (US)
A lemming, Mark? Is that like a drowned rat? How DO you come up with some
of these?
I think it's tough to be objective when defining this fan base. We're
talking about something that we feel compares to no other. I've recently
talked with fans of Barry Manilow and Ricky Martin, (both are currently
touring here) and there's a real passion that exists for them, too. They
feel that same sense of community with like minded people. (I know it's
hard to believe) I hear comments like "No one does it for me, like he
does!" "He's such a prolific songwriter" (Sound familiar?)
In that sense they're no different from us, Beauty (along with music
appreciation) lies in the eyes (and ears) of the beholder. Of course I
like to think that this community will never fall apart, it doesn't wax
and wane because of tours or lack of a new record. I think I can speak for
all of us that we're never getting off this train? So what if Ricky has
more T shirt sales than Bruce! |
| CosmicKid |
posted
05-19-2000 07:06 PM PT (US)
As some of you might remember, a few months ago I offered some server
space for a questionnaire that my friend Nana wanted us Bruce fans to
answer. She got a lot of responses and also interviewed a lot of people in
person. Not just Bruce fans, but fans of everybody from Cliff Richard to
Aqua. Well, I've had several extremely interesting conversations with her
about what she has found out about the various fan groups. And one of the
things she says is that Bruce, unlike others, are extremely aware of their
own fandom and what it implies. The fact that we're even having this
conversation on a fairly high intellectual level is quite unusual. Bruce
fans are also very cautious about not going "over the top" and
to maintain a life outside the Bruce world. There are probably other
aspects, too, that make us special, if not better or worse than other
fans. If there's any interest I could get Nana to chime in with her
opinion as an outsider who talked to a lot of different fans. |
| bbb |
posted
05-19-2000 08:38 PM PT (US)
Sure, every artist(s) has some die-hard fans, but I think there has only
been one group that has had a more intense following and (even though I
just don't get it and have no interest in them) that is the Grateful Dead. |
| Miami
MArk |
posted
05-19-2000 09:33 PM PT (US)
Did not want to say it but you are so right. The Deads fan base could not
be broken even when they were uuhhhmm....DEAD! I see the same faces at the
Other Ones shows that I have been seeing for years at the Dead. And
another thing I want to mention is that the Deads following do it without
the, lets just say...affluence...that most Springsteen fans have. As for
not going over the top, I thought I saw someone above comment about Bruce
mobilizing us as an army in a cause. well that US is gonna have to remain
YOU!I do not want to fight world hunger, or save the rainforest, or build
a mexican releif center. If he wants to use his money to do that ...cool.
Once it is out of my pocket and into his....its his. But I am there for
the music, that is what it is all about, that is what makes the
connection. It is funny, Bruce didn't introduce me to other music, it was
other music which brought me to Bruce. So the music will always be the
pillar for me. Remember what he said "Blind faith in your
leaders...." |
| brilliantly
disguised |
posted
05-20-2000 04:40 AM PT (US)
Interesting topic--a few ideas come to mind though about devoted fan
bases--
for some reason, Jimmy Buffet always sells out around here in like, 30
min. for our 20,000 seat amphitheatre. Same with Phish.
Pearl Jam has a monster following on the road. As does the Dave Matthews
band.Dave played 2 sold out shows here last summer that both sold out the
day of sale.
When they toured, Pink Floyd was a tough ticket anywhere.And of course,
same for the ageless Stones.And probably u2.
Not my taste, but I can first-hand vouch for the followers of
Metallica...a buddy of mine is a former roadie of theirs and they too have
pilgrims that follow them.
good topic--I think Bruce Tramps are at, or near, the top of any
devoted fan list. |
| Magnus |
posted
05-20-2000 09:07 AM PT (US)
Karsten, I would love to hear from Nana on this topic (has she gotten to
any shows yet at all?)
I would be careful about assuming that we are more diehard a community
than that of other artists (or sports teams or other obscure hobbies), but
I guess I always assumed that the message of community in Bruce's music
perhaps was reflected in the following behind him. I have no idea what the
fan commumities of other groups are like, but I hear that the Deadheads
are pretty diehard and the fans of Van Morrison are very helpfull and
friendly when it comes to tape trading etc.
On one hand there are loads of stories about Bruce fans helping each
other out with tix to shows and bootlegs and stuff just out of the
kindness of their hearts and because it seemed like the decent thing to
do. On the other hand, a example of exactly the opposite kind of thing, is
the mysterious exclusive traders who have loads of live and studio
material that they don't share with others for some reason beyond my
comprehension. I sometimes wonder if these traders are just in it for the
money.
|
| tickbitty |
posted
05-22-2000 02:22 PM PT (US)
affluence?! US? HA - most of the so-called "dead heads" that I
know have a lot more money than I do - appearances are deceiving! I still
see lots of the "kids" at other shows, allman bros. for example,
they drive up in saabs and BMW's and then go beg for "a miracle"
free ticket, with their blonde dreadlocks. Puhlease! (not to offend
anyone, - sorry)
On the fan base, does anyone have or remember the article from Rolling
stone in the mid 80's, that had a center photo and profiles of the
different typology of Bruce Fans? If you've got it, post here what issue
it was, I'd love to get ahold of it. A guy I went to school with was one
of those profiled. I can't remember much about the article but it would be
funny to read with 15 more years of perspecctive!
|
| tom
wilson |
posted
05-22-2000 09:52 PM PT (US)
In my opinion the main difference is
Bruce concerts and his music are about his fans as much as about him.
Bruce fans are a
community that has a lot of the same beliefs and ideals.
|
| Miami
MArk |
posted
05-22-2000 09:59 PM PT (US)
The cost of a seat in sec 119 row A for opening night was $825.00 this
morning. You show me a Dead fan who is affluent enough to pay that. The
fact that the scalpers know we CAN pay is as much a driving force in
sending the prices up as the fact we WILL pay. Not gonna argue over this,
but it is the truth. Sure we are different, much the same way Parrotheads
are different. We are different in the SAME way. |
| brilliantly
disguised |
posted
05-23-2000 05:22 AM PT (US)
Deadheads are more about the style, attitude and...ummm...chemical
stimulation than the music. Trust me. I work with some of them. They
barely know song lyrics much less what they mean. I have been subjected to
hours of the DEAD and some of the boots are so brutal, you would HAVE to
be wasted to like them...esp. the 20 minute version of THE NITE THEY DROVE
OL DIXIE DOWN that sounds like a time warp...off key, missed notes, OH GOD
JUST SHOOT ME...
When I go see any show I want to hear as many differant songs as possible,
not 5 songs dragged out 3 hours so I can get a BUZZZZ....Bruce makes us
think, rock, and wears us out. And he NEVER does 20 minute cover songs! |
| Miami
MArk |
posted
05-23-2000 07:52 AM PT (US)
Never does 20 min covers? See: Sweet Soul Music, Quarter to three, Detroit
Medley, Mustang Sally, Midnight Hour, Twist and Shout, Little Latin Lupe
Lu, Carol, Little Queenie....any and all of which I would pay to see
again. |
| karen |
posted
05-23-2000 08:42 AM PT (US)
I took a Bruce virgin to her first show last fall, (she was reluctant to
pay the $150 for an upper level seat) I just remember that when the lights
went on during 'Badlands' she looked at me in disbelief and said, "Oh
my God, everybody here is from middle-class white America!" (she
didn't know that the Europeans most likely coughed up more $$ to be there
too) She said it was at that time, during that song, that she felt like no
other music experience she's ever had, She says it was all because of the
fans! : ) |
| tickbitty |
posted
05-23-2000 02:55 PM PT (US)
825$?! I bet there are plenty of Bruce fans not affluent enough to pay
that for a ticket either (70$ twice was actually a big chunk of dough for
me!) Just as I bet there are quite a number of deadheads who could or
would pay it...(a mute anyway point since ol'jer-bear is dead!) Miami you
must make some good money buddy! I will give you that a
"typical" dead fan, and a "typical" bruce fan,
(whatever those might be) probably come from different backgrounds,
economic or otherwise. |
| Sherry
Darling |
posted
05-23-2000 03:12 PM PT (US)
They may cost $825 but can Bruce or his staff DO anything about that?
Since they are scalped tickets? NO ONE minds making money. I agree, Miami,
that Bruce is quite rich and I also agree that many fans don't like to
think of him that way simply because of his persona and his message. I
don't have a problem with it myself. The content of his music never
changed, he has never stopped meaning it and even the most commerical
album, BiTUSA, was consistent with his message and was quality stuff
compared to much of what it out there. If he's making tons of cash from
it, more power to him, he's done it because of his talent, determination,
courage to take risks and some good business moves I'd imagine courtesy of
Landau. :) I *would* have a problem with it, though, if he didn't put any
of his money where is guitar is, though, and he does. And his music does
inspire me to support the causes we agree on; he's said in interviews this
is a goal. Sign me up for the army. but I totally respect someone being
there just for the music, too.
Sherry Darlin' |
| tom
wilson |
posted
05-23-2000 08:54 PM PT (US)
Bruce tickets are like Playoff tickets
The real fan sits at home and watches while
some rich prick decides he has to go. The best part is the show is not
worth $50 if you
do not get the meaning of it. A real fan can
listen to a bootleg over and over and still be right beside the band
|
| Miami
MArk |
posted
05-23-2000 09:39 PM PT (US)
I did not say I paid that much for the tix!!! Bruce would have to come
home and make me dinner for that much! But Tom you gotta admit, the
playoffs...at THE GARDEN...c'mon Tom...that CD will wear out before the
memories do. ME....I wanna be where the bands are!!! |
| tom
wilson |
posted
05-23-2000 09:55 PM PT (US)
Mark, the playoffs for our Raptors were no fun at the Garden, maybe next
year.
PS I traded my hockey play-off tickets for Bruce, best trade ever made.NJ
killed us
Damn New York teams (Yanks too) |