2009-11-22
Nostalgia is just another rule broken

As I'm writing this Bruce and the band are gearing up for the last show of the tour, in Buffalo, NY. It is also by Bruce's own words the last show with the E Street Band "in a while". Some think it will be the last show with the E Street Band ever.

Whatever the case, tonight feels like the end of an era that started 10 years ago with the Reunion Tour. Even if the E Street Band does return - and both Bruce and Jon Landau have indicated that it could very well happen - chances arethere will be some changes in the lineup that will seriously alter the face of the band. Max Weinberg could be forced to stay with the Tonight Show, and Clarence... what about Clarence? While his playing has been better than on the last couple of tours, he looks fragile and in pain. So could tonight be his last show? And without him, can you still call it The E Street Band?

Well, in order to predict the future, it's always a good idea to look back at what has gone before. The tour started only eight months ago, but if you look at the show as it looks today compared to back then, you would hardly even guess they were part of the same tour. Only half a dozen songs from the beginning of the tour have remained stables in the same positions as where they started out. The Working on a Dream album, while never very prominent in the show, has been completely abandoned. "Outlaw Pete" finally saw his own demise in October (except for a short one-off revival in DC) leaving only the title track to represent the album that gave the tour its name.

Instead the tour was taken over by performances of full albums with the Born to Run album being all-dominating. This may be the first time of his career that Bruce has been being glaringly nostalgic. And not that there's necessarily anything wrong with that at this point of his career, but just imagine how that would have been received in 1999 or 2002. Back then he was on a mission to prove that the band was still vital and moving forward. Playing full albums would have made critics and fans write him off as a has-been. Today, 10 years on, Bruce has proven just about all there is to prove and has cleared the road for himself to do and sing whatever he damn well pleases - and broken all his own rules in the process.

That's why even ending the tour tonight in Buffalo with the album that started it all, Greetings From Asbury Park, could be seen as a last, solemn farewell to the band, but could also just be another impulse by Bruce that we shouldn't attach too much importance to. If it's the last E Street Band show ever, we probably won't know it anytime soon, and if it's just the closing of another chapter in the band's history, well, then that shouldn't be a surprise. A lot of things that seemed impossible 10 years ago have happened. Why not another couple of tours further on up the road?

See you then.


Reader comments
molliemouse4 says: There's nothing wrong with nostalgia & there's nothing wrong with innovation. I would pay good money just to watch Bruce Springsteen play nose flute because whatever he does, he does it with such obvious joy & passion which is instantly transmitted to his audience. If fans visibly radiated their emotions during his concerts, then there would be the most vibrant & incandescent of rainbows blazing the night sky over every arena he's played.For me, & I'm sure for many other's, his performances are spiritual.
Boots says: Dude, lighten up and enjoy the fact that the band has been around for so long. If they continue, fantastic, if not, they've had a nice little run.
E says: Whatever happens, we'll always have Paris. And Barcelona. And London. And Bilbao. And...
Bruce L. says: While it common knowledge that Clarence needs to get physically better,, Max has always been able to juggle his Conan gig with E-Street Band tours. At this point,, as we all are getting older, health of all these great musicians is the biggest issue. If they feel great in two years, Bruce (by Steve's admission,) has alot of music in the can, and ready for the band to play. In the meantime, happy vacation to all the crew and bandmembers... and we will see you for the last tour sometime in Mid 2011
Captain Puget says: Dear Mr. Springsteen and E Street Band,

Well, at age 54 I've been to a few dozen of these Springsteen shows since 1975. I'll let the fellows have a wee bit of a rest, but unless you have a doctors note don't come whining to me. I've kept my work boots lace up between tours and I'm up all night again tonight making an honest living for my wife and kids. So go ahead and go home, get reacquainted with the family have a little down time then get back out here on the road and go to work. That's where I'll be, kickin' ass and takin' names.

Prove it all night, Prove it every night, Prove it all life.
Ryan Wakley says: They have been playing so great for the last two years it will seem a shame to let it all go.
alberto says: As Bruce L said, I would like to say just only one time, we?ll always have Buenos Aires, Argentina for a full Bruce?s concert.
Bruce fan 2009 says: "And without him (Clarence), can you still call it The E Street Band?" Danny died a year and a half ago. Last I heard he was a member of the E Street Band. The band has already left us. Most people just don't seem to know it or want to realize it...When I saw him a month ago it seemed like a nostalgia act. Maybe Bruce has realized he can't create the same music he used to create. He has nothing to be ashamed of. He still sells as many tickets as today's popular artists. I think Bruce can still be relevant and popular even if he changes his music a bit and keeps most of the band. It doesn't have to be all or nothing. Bruce has shown since Danny's untimely death that he will move on minus one E Streeter or two or three. As long as he has fun, enjoys the crowds and wants to make some money, he'll be back in some way, shape or form.

Outlaw Pete says: Bruce fan 2009, how can you say Bruce is a nostalgia act? In the last few years, as well as the awesome E Street Band tours, we've seen Bruce tour solo (Devils & Dust) and tour with the Seeger Sessions Band. Three very different things! God, when Bruce toured with the 92 band, folks complained, then he tours with the E streeters, and folks say it's nostalgia!
Radio Nowhere, Girls in Their Summer Clothes, Outlaw Pete, Kingdom of Days...all new songs, and all great. Who says he can't create anymore? Of course he can't write Born To Run or Thunder Road; he's a different person now, and trying to write songs like that WOULD be turning into a nostalgia act.
mick parkinson says: very well put outlaw pete the same bitchers and whinners will still kill for tickets if another tour is announced !!
Bruce fan 2009 says: I didn't kill for tickets. I got them 3 days before the show. I think he did 5 songs out of 30 from post Rising albums. If you want to know how popular Bruce is now compared to 10 years ago, just look at where he plays and how many nights he plays. We're not looking at 15 shows at the Meadowlands or 10 shows at Giants Stadium anymore. The facts are all there to see. He's still a great performer but let's not act like he's at the peak of his popularity.
Klaus says: Next stop Las Vegas! ;-)
News id:
Your comment:

Your name:

Please note that your comment won't become visible until it has been approved by the editor. We reserve the right to deny comments.